The story
Thoughtful essentials for growing families
Mushie makes safe, stylish, sustainable baby products and essentials. For the Shopify brand, loyalty was a way to give something back to returning customers while inviting new families into the community. Mushie launched its first rewards program with Smile in January 2024.
The challenge
A thank you, not a fix
Mushie did not have a loyalty program before Smile. The goal was not to fix a broken system, but to find a thoughtful way to thank loyal customers and welcome new ones into the brand’s community.
We love our Mushie community and wanted to create a way to give back to our loyal customers while welcoming new ones. Having a rewards program in place felt like a natural way to strengthen those relationships and continue building our community.
The solution
Rewards, referrals and checkout redemption
Before launching, Mushie researched and compared several loyalty platforms. The team chose Smile for the features they needed and the flexibility to support a growing customer base. Since January 2024, the program has become part of Mushie’s existing marketing and retention efforts.
The program gives returning customers a reason to stay engaged and offers new customers another way into the Mushie community. More recently, Mushie made it possible to redeem rewards directly at checkout, making redemption easier at the moment of purchase.
The program
Mushie Rewards
Launched January 2024.
How it works
- 5 points per $1 spent
- 150 points for signing up, and 200 on a birthday
- 50 points each for a product review, a Facebook share and a follow on Instagram or TikTok
- 100 points for $1 off an order, redeemable right at checkout
- A $5 off coupon per referred friend who buys, and $5 off for the friend
The results
Redeemers spend more per order
Mushie’s program is giving the team more ways to recognize returning customers and grow its community. Over the last 12 months, orders placed with a rewards or referral code generated about $78,000 in loyalty-driven revenue. Loyalty revenue rose 105% year over year, and orders placed with a loyalty reward rose 109%. Since launch, customers have placed 1,656 orders using loyalty rewards, totaling more than $125,000.
The focus on returning customers also shows up in order values: customers who redeem rewards spend 133% more per order than those who do not ($98 versus about $42). The redemption rate was 70% higher in the 28 days after Mushie started letting customers redeem rewards right at checkout.
The community has grown to more than 44,000 loyalty members since launch, including more than 20,000 new members in the last 12 months, up 188% year over year.
Seeing repeat customers continue to engage with the brand has been a big win. We love having a way to reward our returning customers while also encouraging new customers to become part of the Mushie community.
The takeaway
Another touchpoint for lasting relationships
For Mushie, Smile is another touchpoint for building lasting customer relationships. The program adds rewards to the brand’s existing marketing and retention efforts, while making room for its growing community of families.

